Extracting
The soul grows by subtraction, not addition. — Thoreau The rare exception, I painted Beer Bottle alla prima from a photo yesterday. (I usually paint from observation.) I’m away from my studio, staying, Thoreau-like, in a cabin in Maine, and can’t set up my subject easily. While still wet, I posted Beer Bottle on a couple of painters’ groups on Facebook. The painting received a rather stinging comment from someone who posts none of her own work: “How about some cast shadows?” I advised her that, in reality (in this case, photographic reality), the cast shadow falls behind the bottle, and is invisible to the viewer. She responded: “Artistic license is an essential part of the process. We can add or subtract as our vision dictates. Shading and shadows add a bit of interest to a rather flat and static composition.” Grrrr. Unless solicited, the rules for these Facebook groups prohibit criticism; but that’s beside the point. Should I wish to paint what I see (even in a photo), ...